The score only narrows the list. Five checks, in this order, lead to one or two tools for a given class. Each rests on facts read on 17 November 2026, on vendor pages or, for Copyleaks prices, on two other sites.
1. Start where students hand in work
Pick a tool that plugs into the platform your students already use, because copying each essay by hand takes time. Pangram names six learning platforms and PlagiarismCheck.org seven. Compilatio Magister names six, including Microsoft Teams. GPTZero links to Canvas and Google Classroom on its Professional plan only. If your school runs Canvas, check that the plugin, a small add-on installed by the school, is on your plan before paying.
2. Count the words you check in a month
Work out your monthly volume, then compare it with each plan's allowance. A teacher with 120 students who checks two 600-word essays each a month needs 144,000 words. That fits Pangram Individual at $20 and Originality.ai Pro at $14.95. It does not fit Winston AI Essential, whose 100,000 credits cover 100,000 words. Copyleaks Personal, at 25,000 words, would cover about a sixth of it.
3. Decide whether you need to see the writing process
A score alone rarely settles a dispute with a student. A writing replay shows how the text grew, keystroke by keystroke, which gives you something concrete to discuss. GPTZero and Grammarly offer a full replay. Pangram and Originality.ai offer it only on Google Docs, through their browser extensions. If your students write on paper, OCR, which reads text from a photo or scan, matters more. Winston AI and Compilatio say they read handwriting, and Pangram reads scanned documents.
4. Check the student-privacy statement
Ask what happens to student essays before you upload a class set. FERPA, the US law that protects student records, is the usual test. Four of the ten name FERPA on their own site: Pangram, GPTZero and PlagiarismCheck.org state compliance, and Originality.ai only for school contracts. Winston AI, Grammarly, Copyleaks, Sapling and Compilatio list other standards but not FERPA, and ZeroGPT publishes no such list. If your district requires a signed student-data agreement, ask the vendor before you buy.
5. Check the language of the essays
Confirm the languages you grade in, because coverage ranges from two to more than 30. PlagiarismCheck.org detects AI in English and Spanish only. Copyleaks reads 30 languages, Pangram 24 and Winston AI 23. A French or German teacher should rule out a two-language tool, however low its price.