The score only shortlists: it counts capabilities, and the right tool depends on the work done with the photos. Six checks narrow the list to one or two tools. Each one rests on facts read on 15 November 2026, on vendor pages or, for Adobe's prices, on two other sites.
1. Decide whether you organise photos or change them
Photo editing software splits into two kinds, and you should pick the kind before the tool. A RAW editor with a catalogue sorts a whole shoot and adjusts light and colour, like Lightroom, Capture One Pro or darktable. A pixel editor changes the picture itself in layers, like Photoshop, Affinity, Photopea or PaintShop Pro.
If you shoot hundreds of photos a week, the catalogue matters more than layers. If you edit a few images in depth, layers matter more. ON1 Photo RAW, Luminar and PhotoDirector 365 do some of both.
2. Check that your camera's RAW files open
RAW files hold everything the camera sensor recorded, which leaves more room to fix light and colour than a JPEG. Each camera model writes its own RAW format, so support varies. Capture One lists over 550 supported cameras and PaintShop Pro over 800 camera models. Photopea opens the formats of the main brands, such as CR3 and NEF, in a browser.
Look for your exact camera model on the vendor's supported list before you pay, then open a few of your own files during the trial.
3. Count what the AI tools really cost
The same AI tool can be free, paid in credits or locked behind another subscription. Credits are units that each generative edit spends. In Photoshop, an AI enlargement of an image up to 25 megapixels costs 10 credits. In Lightroom, Generative Remove spends no credits. PhotoDirector 365 includes 1,200 credits a year.
Two cases need care. Luminar's generative tools last 365 days on a one-time licence, then need a subscription. Affinity is free, but its AI tools need a paid Canva plan. If you never use generative AI, darktable runs its AI masks and enlargement on your own computer, at no cost.
4. Compare subscriptions with one-time licences over three years
A subscription costs less at the start and more over time. A one-time licence, also called a perpetual licence, is paid once and kept, but usually covers one version. ON1's one-time licence, for example, covers Photo RAW 2027 only, with no future major upgrades.
Over three years, Photoshop alone costs $827.64 on its annual plan paid monthly. PaintShop Pro costs $79.99 once over the same period. The table further down sets every tool side by side at one and three years.
5. Check where the tool runs
Some tools here are limited to certain systems. PaintShop Pro runs on Windows only. darktable's Mac builds need an Apple Silicon Mac, one with Apple's own chip rather than an Intel one. Affinity runs on Mac, Windows and iPad, with no phone app. Capture One's mobile app is for iPhone and iPad, with no Android version.
If you edit on a phone as well as a computer, Lightroom and Luminar sync between the two. If you move between computers you do not own, Photopea needs nothing but a browser.
6. Read the price after the promotion
Several vendors showed promotions on 15 November 2026, and this page uses the list price, the standard price before offers. Luminar's Desktop Only licence showed $99 against a list price of $417. PaintShop Pro showed $47.99 against $79.99.
An offer on a one-time licence is a real saving if you buy during it. On a subscription, check what the second year costs before you pay.