All ten list vacancies, screen tenants, collect rent online and track repairs, so the score only builds the shortlist. Six checks narrow it to one or two tools. Each check rests on vendor pages read on 16 November 2026.
1. Count your units, then read how the price is built
Three pricing models sit side by side here, and your unit count decides which one is cheap. TenantCloud, Rentec Direct Starter and Buildium Essential charge a flat monthly price. AppFolio, DoorLoop and Yardi Breeze charge per unit, each with a minimum. Landlord Studio includes 3 units in Pro and adds $1.20 a month for each unit beyond. RentRedi charges one price for any number of units.
Take a landlord with 10 units on monthly billing. TenantCloud and Rentec Direct cost $25 a month, and Buildium $65. Yardi Breeze costs $100, because of its minimum. AppFolio bills at least 50 units. At 50 units, TenantCloud moves to Pro at $60 and Rentec Direct to Pro at $100. Price your size before you look at features.
2. Find out who pays each rent payment
Online rent is not free: each bank transfer, called an ACH payment in the US, carries a fee. The question is who pays it. On RentRedi, TenantCloud, DoorLoop One and Innago, the tenant pays that fee by default. On Landlord Studio, the landlord chooses who pays the $2.50. On Buildium, the landlord pays $2.35 per incoming payment on Essential. Yardi Breeze and Rentec Direct Pro charge $0 for a bank payment.
Ten tenants paying by bank each month cost a Buildium Essential landlord $23.50 a month in fees. That adds more than a third to the $65 subscription. If you want tenants to pay nothing extra, pick a tool where the bank payment is free or where you can absorb a small fee.
3. Decide whether the same tool keeps the books
Some tools only collect rent; others keep full books for tax time. Full books here means a bank feed, which brings the transactions of a bank account into the software, and a report for Schedule E. Schedule E is the US tax form where rental income and costs are declared.
Landlord Studio keeps both for Pro, at $15 a month; its free Go plan tracks income and expenses by hand. TurboTenant keeps both for Pro, at $199 a year for up to 10 units, against $149 for Essentials. TenantCloud keeps the bank feed for Pro, at $60 a month. Innago has no bank feed of its own: it points to Ledgre, a separate accounting app with its own subscription. If an accountant already keeps your books, the cheaper plans are enough.
4. Price the screening and the lease before the first tenant
Screening means ordering a credit, criminal or eviction report on an applicant. Every tool here offers it, at published prices from $10 to $55 a report. Rentec Direct Pro charges $10 to $18. Buildium charges $17 when the landlord pays. TurboTenant charges the renter $55 on the free plan and $45 on a paid plan.
Leases can cost extra too. Buildium Essential charges $5 for each signed document, so 10 leases a year cost $50. TurboTenant includes e-signatures from Essentials. If your state has its own lease rules, check the tool offers state-specific forms on your plan.
5. Check the owner portal if you manage for others
An owner portal is a login where the owner of a property sees rent, costs and statements without calling you. A landlord who only manages their own units does not need it. A manager who looks after other people's units usually does.
Buildium and DoorLoop include one on every plan, and AppFolio and Yardi Breeze offer one too. TenantCloud keeps it for Pro and Rentec Direct for PM. TurboTenant has none. RentRedi and Innago give owners a read-only login without statements. On Landlord Studio, owners serve only to filter reports. A manager with 20 units for owners pays $50 a month on Rentec PM, the plan's minimum.
6. Compare monthly and yearly billing
Yearly billing lowers most prices, but it asks for twelve months up front. RentRedi costs $29.95 a month billed monthly, or $144 a year billed yearly. TurboTenant sells its paid plans by the year only: the $12.42 on its pricing page is $149 divided by twelve.
A RentRedi landlord who pays monthly for a year spends $359.40, against $144 on the yearly plan. Yardi Breeze is billed monthly but signed for a year. Pay monthly while you try a tool, then switch to yearly once your tenants are set up.